Thank you for being one of the +4,500 minds reading this newsletter
Here is what youâll find in this edition:
[Essay] Appleâs lost decade
An Eastern European Saga
A parallel between đ Apple and đ´ Huawei
NVIDIA is âALL INâ
đ My investment thesis (part 1)
âŚand more đ
Onto the update:
[Essay] Appleâs lost decade
Apple made a strategic choice a decade ago and it chose comfort (and a lot of money)
Instead of building the future, it took a dividend from the present. While Google plowed billions into search, data infrastructure, and foundational AI research, Apple signed a check to license Google Search as the default on Safari. That check, estimated at over $20 billion per year, was enough to keep Appleâs services revenue growing, but it was also the price of a decade-long delay in understanding how to work with data at scale.
Today, that decision has metastasized into the embarrassment that is Siri, the me-too nature of âApple Intelligenceâ, and the companyâs palpable absence from every major AI inflection point.
...Continue reading HERE.
An Eastern European Saga
Putin keeps insisting his war is about NATO and ânazisâ, but the more boring and therefore more accurate explanation is that itâs about GDP math (ie. prosperity). Since 1990, the former communist countries that joined the EU have grown their economies almost 10x, while Russia has managed barely 4x.
đľđą Poland, Slovakia, the Baltics, đˇđ´ Romania: skyscrapers, highways, and EU per-capita income curves that leave Russia in the dust. And sitting right next door is Ukraine - the âtipping point stateâ. If đşđŚ Ukraine prospers as an EU member, Russians will start asking awkward questions: âWhy do people who look, speak, and eat like us have a functioning economy while we have crony oil rents and kleptocracy?â
Thatâs why the war isnât really foreign policy, but itâs internal policy disguised as external aggression. Ukraine canât be allowed to thrive, not because of NATO tanks but because of Russian pensioners with Youtube and cousins in Warsaw. The invasion is basically regime maintenance: stop the mirror from reflecting back to your own people how badly youâve run the place.
If Ukraineâs equity story is âEastern Europe at EU multiplesâ, then Russiaâs governance risk is that shareholders (citizens) realize theyâve been holding the wrong stock all along. WSJ
A parallel between Apple and Huawei
Two mirror books: âHouse of Huaweiâ (Eva Dou) and âApple in Chinaâ (Patrick McGee). Read together, they show how elite firms are bent and turbocharged by Chinaâs political economy.
It was a coincidence that I read them one after another, so I got the chance to observe some similarities between these 2 companies:
1/ work as devotion - both books detail the âbest place to workâ myth cultures that ask for your all (time, health, identity) in exchange for belonging and velocity. That bargain looks heroic in brochures and costly in real life.
2/ state-enabled scale - Huawei grows as a national champion; Appleâs miracle rides on local (Chinese) government incentives, bonded zones, and a supplier state (hello, Foxconn). Different relationships, but same outcome: public power underwriting private dominance.
3/ control and captivity - described by company towns and closed ecosystems (campuses, dorms, secrecy) create astonishing throughput and strategic traps. Huawei is bound to the party-state, while Apple is bound to China. Each is âcapturedâ by its own success.
If you build, invest, or teach strategy, read both books side-by-side. Amazon
NVIDIA is âALL INâ
Hereâs Nvidiaâs $100 billion idea: build âAI factoriesâ. Translation: âreally big data centers with a shocking electricity billâ. The logic is circular but elegant: Nvidia gives OpenAI the money to buy Nvidiaâs chips so that OpenAI can rent those chips back from Nvidia to make ChatGPT spit out slightly wittier answers. The investment âsecuresâ demand while pretending itâs diversification, which is a very Nvidia thing to do. By investing in NVIDIA, you invest indirectly in OpenAI
The fun part is that everyone knows the economics donât really add up. Bain says the industry would need $2 trillion in revenue by 2030 just to sustain the capital spending required, and weâre currently short by about $800 billionďżź. But Nvidia doesnât care. Jensen Huang is running the MicrosoftâIntel playbook rolled into one, except instead of Windows on your desktop youâve got CUDA on your datacenter. Itâs less about selling GPUs and more about keeping every ambitious AI lab hopelessly addicted. The factories are just the crack houses. An AI bubble is forming. FT
Whoâs doing the strategy at BMW?
BMW has decided that the future of the X5 is⌠all the futures, all at once:
Petrol
Diesel
Hybrid
Electric
and now hydrogen. đ
Which is kind of like hedging by buying every option on the board, then bragging about your âtechnology leadershipâ because youâre paying five times the R&D, five times the production complexity, and five times the supply chain headaches. Hydrogen, of course, is the funniest line item: thereâs no infrastructure, no market, and no realistic economics, but BMW swears it has âan essential role in global decarbonisationâ. Translation: âWe spent billions on this already and canât admit it was a bad idea.â
Imagine proudly announcing that your genius strategy is to make cars for every possible energy source, including one that requires filling stations which donât exist and never will because theyâre too expensive. Itâs like saying, âOur leadership is so strong we can lose money five different waysâ. Meanwhile, Tesla and BYD are doing the boring thing: picking one lane, scaling it, and crushing costs. BMW, on the other hand, is out here building a hydrogen SUV for a hydrogen world that exists only in... powerpoint slides? Leadership indeed. LINK
đŠđŞ Germany is changing too
Germanyâs industrial policy for decades was basically: âWe make cars. The world buys cars. End of story / policyâ. And for a while, it worked. Autos & Parts sat comfortably at 18â20% of the German market, carrying the DAX on their Teutonic shoulders. But the chart says it all: now autos are below 10%, and tech, of all things, is the sector bailing them out. In Germany! The place where âsoftwareâ was historically something you installed off a CD-ROM in 2004âŚor a floppy disk đž
Itâs a remarkable reversal: instead of Audi and BMW dictating market weight, youâve got SAP and a handful of industrial tech firms suddenly doing the heavy lifting. The German car industry spent the last decade lobbying Brussels to regulate tailpipe emissions into fairy dust, while China quietly built an EV juggernaut. Now Volkswagen canât sell EVs (and is bad at software - see the partnership with Rivian), Mercedes & BMW are playing with hydrogen fantasy projects (ie. building another monopoly), and the market is saying: âYou know what, maybe the future isnât German exhaust pipes, maybe itâs cloud softwareâ. When the DAX looks more like Nasdaq than Detroit, you know the old order has cracked.
No rare earth minerals, no moat
Hereâs Europeâs big strategy on rare earths: fly to Beijing, smile for the cameras with Xi, announce an âupgraded dialogue on export controlsâ, and then fly home hoping the paperwork gets easier. Two months later, 140 licence applications are stuck in limbo, only a quarter resolved, and European manufacturers are bleeding money waiting for magnets and metals that China controls from mine to refinery. This is exactly a REAL preview of what happens when your entire industrial base runs on inputs owned by your geopolitical rival.
What did they think was going to happen? That China would politely keep feeding the EU raw materials while the US and Europe throw tariffs at its exports? If you donât secure your own supply chain (by investing in EU processing, by building alliances with Africa, Latin America, or Australia) then you donât really have a supply chain, you have a dependency. And when that dependency moves from rare earths to chips, to AI, to defense tech, the delays will redefine power.
This is the first serious warning and Europeâs response so far is to ask for more âdialogueâ. Good luck with that. FT
Premier League and the rest
The top 10 football clubs by revenue are more a business case study in how strategy, branding, and structural advantages compound than a sports ranking.
Real Madrid and Manchester City illustrate Porterâs âdifferentiation + scaleâ model where star players and global trophies translate into premium commercial contracts, with broadcast rights amplifying reach.
PSG and Barcelona run closer to âbig bets on talent as strategyâ, banking on superstars to drive shirt sales and sponsorships, which Rumelt would probably call a bad strategy if it lacks a coherent financial foundation.
Manchester United shows Bradley et al.âs âhockey stickâ fallacy, betting on the brand curve to bend upward without making the bold moves (on-pitch results, stadium reinvention) that sustain revenue.
Bayern and Arsenal embody pricing power in Simon-Kucherâs terms. Consistent Champions League appearances and loyal fan bases mean they can extract more value per seat, per jersey, per sponsor.
Two more ideas:
1/ First, football clubs are global entertainment platforms.
2/ Second, the gap between winners and laggards is about structural advantages in commercial deals, market size, and organizational execution. As Porter would put it, the âvalue chainâ for a football club is more about how effectively you monetize millions of eyeballs. Bloomberg
đ My investment thesis (part 1)
1/ Time arbitrage. I invest long-term (i.e., minimum 2â3 years) so that fundamentals can outperform headlines.
2/ Concentrate to compound. To beat the market, hold max 10 positions. Know them better than anyone.
3/ Indexes are fine. Exceptional businesses are finer. Buffett didnât build Berkshire by hugging the S&P.
4/ Reinvestment > dividends. Companies that share dividends or engage in buybacks often lack a clear understanding of how to utilize the money.
5/ Moat or bust. I only buy durable advantages: switching costs, network effects, scale efficiencies, brand, regulation, IP, privileged distribution, or proprietary data.
(part 2 to continue)
P.S. In October, I will launch a newsletter on company analysis showing where the moat lies and what my exact portfolio đ. Of course, under a paywall đ











